Two Types of Coronal Bright Points in the 24-th Cycle of Solar Activity

Two Types of Coronal Bright Points in the 24-th Cycle of Solar Activity
Chori T. Sherdanov, Ekaterina P. Minenko, A.M. Tillaboev, Isroil Sattarov.
Abstract We applied an automatic program for identification of coronal bright 5
points (CBPs) to the data obtained by SOHO/EIT observations taken at the 6
wavelength 195 °A, in the time interval from the end of the 23rd to the early 24th 7
solar cycle.We studied the total number of CBPs and its variations at the beginning 8
of the given cycle of solar activity, so that the development of the solar activity 9
could be predicted with the use of CBPs. For a primary reference point for the 24th 10
solar cycle, we took the emergence of a high-latitude sunspot with the reversed 11
polarity, which appeared in January, 2008. We show that the observed number of 12
CBPs reaches the highest point around the minimum of the solar activity, which in 13
turn may result from the effect of visibility. The minimum solar activity at this time 14
provides the opportunity to register the number of CBPs with the highest accuracy, 15
with its uniform latitudinal distribution. We also study the properties of CBPs in a 16
new 24th cycle of solar activity. It is shown that variations in the cyclic curve of 17
the number of coronal bright points associated with variations in the solar activity, 18
for the latitudes of the quiet Sun to be anticorrelation characteristic changes in the 19
number CBPs to the solar activity, and the observational data are for the regions of 20
active formations on the Sun almost identical on character on the equatorial latitude, 21
but this have lightly expressed character in high-latitude zone. To explain the cyclic 22
curves of variation in the number of coronal bright points in connection with the 23
AQ1 C.T. Sherdanov (_) _ I. SattarovAstronomical Institute AS of Uzbekistan, 33 Astronomical str., Tashkent 100052, Uzbekistan
Tashkent State Pedagogical University, 103 Yusuf Khos Khojib Street, Tashkent 100100,
Uzbekistan
E.P. MinenkoAstronomical Institute AS of Uzbekistan, 33 Astronomical str., Tashkent 100052, Uzbekistan
V.N. Obridko et al. (eds.), The Sun: New Challenges, Astrophysics and Space
Science Proceedings 30, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-29417-4 18,
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012
C.T. Sherdanov et al.
solar cycle in different latitudinal zones, we suggest a hypothesis of the existence of 24
two types of coronal bright points: those associated with the quiet corona and those 25
related to active formations. 26
1 Introduction 27
Bright X-ray points (XRTs, or coronal bright points, CBPs)—see their identification 28
AQ2 29
temperature about 2–4 millionK and the average lifetime between 8 h and 2 days 30
31
small (less than 60 arcsec in diameter) to have been discovered with the previous 32
generation of X-ray telescopes. Later, the coronal bright points were also identified 33
with the extreme ultraviolet telescope (EIT/SOHO) and called EIT bright points or 34
EUV bright spots, according to the wavelength at which they were observed. Bright 35
points are recorded in the photosphere, in the corona, and in the transition zone 36
37
Bright points have central cores of approximately 10,000km in diameter and 38
generally occur over the areas of opposite magnetic polarity in the photosphere, 39
when the regions of opposite polarity meet and destroy each other, releasing energy 40
41
formations can also occur when a newly emerging magnetic field interacts with the 42
existing magnetic field in the corona, again with the release of magnetic energy, 43
which heats the gas. Being short-lived, transient objects, they are distributed almost 44
evenly over all latitudes [2], and are observed in the equator, in active and quiet 45
regions, and in coronal holes. 46
Despite the fact that the bright points have been studied both theoretically and 47
observationally, numerous questions related to the formation of these bright spots 48
in the lower corona (or rather in the transition zone between the chromosphere and 49
corona) still remain unanswered. For example, it is still unclear how these structures 50
emit energy and what is their role in the formation of the solar activity and solar 51
radiation, whether they have a pronounced magnetic field, whether the effect of 52
visibility is the only mechanism responsible for the anticorrelation of CBPs figures 53
and sunspots, how the transients evolve, what is their connection with the corona 54
heating and solar wind, etc. 55
The Sun, as a magneto-active star, has a strong magnetic field which, on average 56
and on a large scale, is described as a magnetic dipole. The axis of this dipole 57
changes its direction to opposite approximately every 11 years, which corresponds 58
to the 11-year cycle of the solar activity; in turn, it is reflected in the sunspot cycle 59
measured by the Wolf numbers. 60
Based on the data from SOHO, we constructed a curve of solar activity for 61
the time interval from 1996 to 2011 (see Fig. 1). In the course of observations in 62
Tashkent, the first appearance of a high-latitude spot was recorded on November 3, 63
2008 in the northern hemisphere, which indicates the beginning of the 24th solar 64
Two Types of Coronal Bright Points in the 24-th Cycle of Solar Activity
Fig. 1 Solar activity from1996 to early 2011

cycle. The diagram (Fig. 1) shows that the second observed minimum of the 23rd 65
solar cycle occurred at the end of 2008–2009, which yields the length of the cycle 66
of about 13 years. The dynamics of the observed variations in the cycle and the 67
comparison with the cyclic changes in the curves of CBPs for different latitudes can 68
indicate not only the degree of the dependence of the CBPs phase on the phase of 69
the solar activity cycle, but also will make it possible to hypothetically forecast the 70
subsequent likelihood in the development of the further cycle. 71
2 Observations and Data Analysis 72
In this study, we use a series of data (an average of four images per day) obtained 73
from the extreme ultraviolet telescope EIT installed on board of SOHO mission. The 74
data were taken at the wavelength 195 °A from the 23rd to the beginning of the 24th 75
solar cycle. The data were obtained using an automatic program for identification of 76
coronal bright points (CBPs); the cyclic curves for different latitudes are constructed 77
on the basis of these data.We studied the distribution of coronal bright points on the 78
solar disk for different latitudes, for the quiet Sun and for active regions on the Sun, 79
in order to identify patterns of variations in the 23rd—the beginning of 24th cycles 80
of solar activity and to predict the nature of the cycle development. 81
We plotted the curves of the cyclic changes in the number of CBPs for the quiet 82
Sun (QS) and for active regions of the Sun (AS) at different latitudes, to detect a 83
connection with the cycle of solar activity (SA), processing the data derived from 84
the images at the wavelength of 19.5 nm (EIT/SOHO) within the time interval 1996– 85
2010. The hypothesis of the existence of two types of CBPs is discussed in more 86
detail in the studies of Golub et al. AQ3 [1] and Sattarov et al. (2010) [8]. 87
The diagrams in Fig. 2 show the cyclic curves of the variation in the number of 88
CBPs: a curve of the total number of CBPs and of the numbers in three latitude 89
C.T. Sherdanov et al.

zones, at the equator between C5ı and _5ı, in the zone of active formations (˙ j 90
25ı _ 35ı j), and at high latitudes (˙ j 45ı _ 55ı j). For the sake of clarity, the 91
curves are compared with the total variation in the CBPs number, for the quiet and 92
active Sun, respectively. It is clearly seen that the variation in the number of CBPs at 93
different latitudes has a different character depending on the variation in the phase 94
of the solar activity. Thus, in the zone of active regions and at the equator, variations 95
in the total number of CBPs (Fig. 2, column GN) do not show a significant link with 96
the solar activity cycle, whereas at the high latitude zone the anticorrelation between 97
the number of CBPs and the phase of solar activity is clearly seen. This result will 98
be discussed below.When the data for the total width of the Quiet Sun (QS) and for 99
active regions in the Sun (AS) are separated, another pattern is seen: in this case, 100
correlation is observed only at high latitudes. 101
The analysis of the cyclic curves showed the decline in the total cyclic curve for 102
the CBPs (Fig. 2 GN-a–d) in 1998 and 1999. This decline is noted at the equator and 103
visible for the active regions. The solar activity grew steadily to its maximum in the 104
early 2000–2001, without sharp peaks. There was a sharp drop in the solar activity 105
in the 23rd cycle in 2001 followed by an increase in 2002 (the difference was about 106
2 years).Two Types of Coronal Bright Points in the 24-th Cycle of Solar Activity
For the cyclic curve of the total number of CBPs in high-latitude areas (Fig. 2 108
GN, d) a reverse relationship with the cycle of solar activity is observed; the number 109
of CBPs was in anticorrelation with variations in the solar activity. 110
It should be noted that the number of CBPs varies with the solar activity, and 111
the cyclic curve of CBPs not only displays a distinct two-humped pattern, but also 112
shows anticorrelation between the number of CBPs and the cycle of solar activity at 113
all latitudes of the quiet Sun. The tendency of the cyclic curve of CBPs on the quiet 114
Sun to form the double-hump shape is seen for the equator, in active regions, and at 115
high latitudes. For high-latitude zones of solar activity, this trend is not typical. Also 116
the AS and QS’s cyclic curves more clearly display the solar activity minimum 117
in 2009, while on the curve of solar activity (Fig. 1) the minimum value can be 118
traced from the end of 2008 to the middle 2009. Also can be more clearly observe 119
of the solar activity minimum in 2009 on the AS and QS’s cyclic curves of the 120
number CBPs, while on the curve of solar activity (Fig. 1) the period of solar activity 121
minimum can be traced with the end of 2008 to the middle 2009. 122
The cyclic curve of the CBPs on the active Sun is more or less consistent with 123
the solar activity phases (see Fig. 2 GN, a), with the only difference in the graph 124
of the total number CBPs in the cyclic curve AS (Fig. 2, AS, a), which shows a 125
small but rather sharp jump in the number of CBPs from mid-1997 to early 1998; 126
the SA curve during this period displays a more uniform growth. At the equator, the 127
maximum number of CBPs is seen only in 2001–2002, and an increase in the CBPs 128
number begins only in 2000, while the growth of the 23rd solar activity cycle starts 129
at the beginning of 1998 and reaches its peak in 2000 (with the delay of about 2 130
years). The equator is characterized by a broad profile of the cyclic curve of CBPs 131
for both the active and quiet Sun. 132
133
The following conclusions can be made from the study: 134
• Variations in the number of CBPs during a solar cycle cannot be explained only 135
by the effect of visibility for the equatorial and high latitudes. 136
• The number of CBPs at different latitudes varies differently, depending on the 137
phase of solar activity. 138
• To explain the cyclic curve of variations in the number of coronal bright points 139
in connection with the solar cycle in different latitude zones, we suggest the 140
hypothesis of the existence of two types of coronal bright points: those connected 141
to the quiet corona and to active formations. 142
• The difference between the numbers of coronal bright points in the years of the 143
minimum and maximum of the solar activity for the same latitude is different 144
for the quiet and active Sun, and one can trace the following relationship: the 145
Quiet Sun displays an inverse relationship, with the double-humped shape of 146
the distribution, and with the number of CBPs in anticorrelation with the cycle 147
C.T. Sherdanov et al.
of the solar activity; in the Active Sun’s regions, the variations of the number of 148
CBPs almost correspond to those of the solar activity cycle. 149
• Regarding the SA curve, we can forecast the development of the next peak in the 150
late 2012–early 2013. A more detailed analysis and conclusions, with more data 151
obtained for 2 years to provide further CBP analysis will confirm our hypothesis. 152
• Our suggested determination of the solar activity using cyclic curves and two 153
types of CBPs (AS and QS) describes more clearly the phase of the cycle in the 154
corona. 155
156
214 , L141 (1977). 157
158
159
160
189, L93 (1974).161
3. Golub, L., Davis, J.M., Krieger, A.S.: Astrophys. J. , L145 (1979).
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
4. Longcope, D.W., Kankelborg, C.C., Nelson, J.L., Pevtsov, A.A.: Astrophys. J. 553, 429 (2001).
169
170
171
5. Sattarov, I., Pevtsov, A.A., Hojaev, A.S., Sherdonov, C.T.: Astrophys. J. 564, 1042 (2002).
172
6. Sattarov, I., Pevtsov, A.A., Karachik, N.V., Sherdanov, Ch.T.: In: Stepanov, A.V., Benevolen-
173
skaya, E.E., Kosovichev, A.G. (eds.) Multi-Wavelength Investigations of Solar Activity, IAU
174
Symp. , 667 (2005a).
175
177
346
180
8. Sattarov I., Pevtsov A., Karachik N., Sherdanov Ch., Tillaboev. Solar Phys. , 321–335
(2010).
184
185
186
144, 15–35 (1993).
187
188
AUTHOR QUERIES
AQ1. Please note that the first author has been treated as corresponding author.
Please check and provide email address for all authors.
AQ2. Please note that the reference “Sattarov et al. 2004” is present in the text but
not present in the list. Please provide the reference in the list or delete it from
the text.
AQ3. Please note that the reference “Sattarov et al. (2007)” is present in the text
but not present in the list. Please provide the reference in the list or delete it
from the text.
AQ4. Please note that the references “[1–3, 5, 8–18, 20, 21, 23]” are present in the
list but not present in the text. Please provide the in-text citation or delete
this from the reference list.